Dr. John Gottman’s research found four habits that predict trouble in a marriage: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. Each “horseman” has an antidote. Learn to spot these patterns in your own marriage and replace them with habits that build trust and closeness.
The Four Horsemen: Four Habits That Hurt a Marriage, and How to Stop Them
Every couple argues. But according to decades of research by Dr. John Gottman, how couples argue tells us a great deal about where their marriage is headed. After studying thousands of couples in his “Love Lab,” Dr. Gottman identified four negative communication patterns that, when they become habits, are strong predictors of a marriage in trouble.
He named them the Four Horsemen, after the four horsemen of the Apocalypse in the book of Revelation: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. They tend to show up one after another, each making room for the next.
Here’s the hopeful part: every horseman has an antidote. Once you learn to recognize these patterns in your own marriage, you can replace them with healthier habits. As mentors trained in the Gottman approach, we’ve seen couples turn things around by doing exactly that.
1. Criticism
What it is: Criticism attacks your spouse’s character or personality instead of addressing a specific behavior. A complaint says, “This bothered me.” Criticism says, “There’s something wrong with you.” It often starts with “You always…” or “You never…”
- Complaint: “I was worried when you didn’t call to say you’d be late.”
- Criticism: “You never think about anyone but yourself. You’re so inconsiderate.”
The antidote: a gentle start-up. Talk about your feelings and needs instead of your spouse’s flaws. Use “I” statements and make a positive request:
“I felt worried when I didn’t hear from you tonight. Could you send me a quick text next time you’re running late?”
The issue is the same, but your spouse hears a request rather than an attack, which makes it much easier for them to respond with care.
2. Contempt
What it is: Contempt goes beyond criticism. It communicates, “I’m better than you.” It shows up as sarcasm, mockery, name-calling, eye-rolling, sneering or hostile humor. Contempt grows from long-simmering negative thoughts about your spouse that haven’t been dealt with.
- Contempt: “Oh, you’re tired? Poor thing. I’ve been working all day too, but I guess your job is just so much harder than mine.” (said with an eye-roll)
Dr. Gottman’s research found contempt to be the single greatest predictor of divorce. It’s deeply painful because it tells your spouse they’re not respected or valued.
The antidote: build a culture of appreciation and respect. Look for what your spouse does right, and say it out loud. Express gratitude for small things every day: “Thanks for making coffee this morning,” or “I really admire how patient you were with the kids tonight.” Gottman found that in stable marriages, couples have about five positive interactions for every negative one during conflict. The more you fill your marriage with fondness and admiration, the less room contempt has to grow.
3. Defensiveness
What it is: Defensiveness is a way of protecting ourselves when we feel attacked, often by making excuses, playing the innocent victim, or turning the blame back on our spouse. It’s an understandable reaction, but it sends the message, “The problem isn’t me, it’s you.” Your spouse ends up feeling unheard, and the conflict escalates.
- Question: “Did you call the insurance company like you said you would?”
- Defensive response: “I’ve been slammed all day! Why is it always my job? You could have called them yourself.”
The antidote: take responsibility. Even if you’re only partly at fault, own your part:
“You’re right, I forgot. I’m sorry. I’ll call them first thing tomorrow morning.”
Accepting responsibility, even for a small piece of the problem, lowers your spouse’s guard and opens the door to working it out together.
4. Stonewalling
What it is: Stonewalling happens when one spouse withdraws from the conversation: shutting down, going silent, looking away, staying busy or walking out. It’s usually a response to contempt or to feeling emotionally overwhelmed. To the stonewaller, it can feel like a way to keep things from getting worse. To the other spouse, it feels like being shut out.
Stonewalling is often linked to flooding: when an argument gets heated, your heart rate rises, stress hormones kick in, and it becomes nearly impossible to listen or think clearly.
The antidote: physiological self-soothing. When you notice you’re flooded, call a time-out:
“I’m feeling overwhelmed and need a break. Can we come back to this in 20 minutes?”
Then spend that time actually calming down. Take a walk, breathe deeply, pray or read. Avoid replaying the argument in your head. When you’ve calmed down, come back and finish the conversation. The promise to return is what turns a pause into a healthy break instead of a wall. (For more, see our post on the 20-Minute Rule.)
The Four Horsemen at a glance
Keep this quick reference handy. When you notice a horseman showing up, reach for its antidote.
| Horseman | What it sounds like | The antidote | Try saying |
|---|---|---|---|
| Criticism | “You always…” / “You never…” | Gentle start-up | “I feel… about… I need…” |
| Contempt | Sarcasm, mockery, eye-rolling | Appreciation and respect | “Thank you for…” / “I admire how you…” |
| Defensiveness | “It’s not my fault…” / “Well, you…” | Take responsibility | “You’re right. I’m sorry for my part.” |
| Stonewalling | Silence, shutting down, walking away | Self-soothing and a break | “I need 20 minutes, then let’s finish this.” |
Remember, every couple slips into these patterns sometimes. The goal isn’t perfection; it’s noticing quickly and repairing.
There is hope
Scripture gave us an antidote to the horsemen long before the research did: “Be completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in love” (Ephesians 4:2). Humility answers defensiveness. Gentleness answers criticism. Patience answers stonewalling. And love, expressed through honor and appreciation, answers contempt.
If you recognize one or more of the horsemen in your marriage, don’t lose heart. Awareness is the first step. Pick one antidote this week and practice it together. Small changes, repeated consistently, can change the direction of a marriage.
At Marriagescape, our mentor couples are trained in the Gottman approach and walk alongside you as you learn to replace these patterns with healthier ones, in every season of marriage. Our Side by Side couples assessment can also show you how each of you handles conflict.
Ready to send the horsemen packing? Contact us today, and let’s take the next step together.
The Four Horsemen and their antidotes were developed by Dr. John Gottman and The Gottman Institute. Learn more at gottman.com.







